Shimla, Nov 18
Himachal Pradesh High Court has set aside an order of the Financial Commissioner (Appeals) directing vesting of land purchased by a private resort company in the State under Section 118 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972, holding that mere failure to complete a project within two years does not automatically warrant vesting of the property.
Allowing a petition filed by M/s Rikhi Resorts Private Limited, Justice Sandeep Sharma quashed the order dated April 2, 2026, passed by the Financial Commissioner (Appeals) and granted the company one-and-a-half years to complete the construction of its resort. The Court, however, made it clear that failure to complete the construction within the extended period would result in the property vesting in the State.
The petitioner company had obtained permission from the State Government on January 24, 1994, under Section 118 of the Act to purchase 5 bighas and 10 biswas of land comprising Khasra Nos. 162, 163, 166 and 167 at Sakori village in Kandaghat tehsil of Solan district for establishing a hotel/resort.
The District Collector, Solan, initiated vesting proceedings in 2009 on the ground that the company had failed to put the land to the permitted use within two years. However, the Collector dropped the proceedings on July 25, 2014, after finding that the company had undertaken construction activities within the stipulated period. The Divisional Commissioner, Shimla, subsequently upheld this decision on August 29, 2017.
The State challenged these orders before the Financial Commissioner (Appeals), which reversed the concurrent findings of the two revenue authorities on April 2, 2026, prompting the company to approach the High Court.
The company argued that its original permission letter did not contain any specific condition requiring the land to be put to use within two years. It further submitted that construction activities had commenced through the construction of a 350-400 metre road, labour huts and foundations for pillars. However, the project could not progress further following the death of its Managing Director.
The State government opposed the petition, maintaining that Section 118(2) itself prescribed the two-year period and that the construction of a road and labour huts could not be treated as commencement of the resort project.
Rejecting the State’s contention, the High Court observed that the permission letter dated January 24, 1994, did not specifically incorporate any two-year time limit for putting the land to use.
The Court observed that an applicant granted permission under Section 118 could not be expected to independently examine the statutory provisions and was required to abide by the terms and conditions communicated through the permission letter.
The Court further held that construction of a resort could not be completed in one go and had to be undertaken in phases. The construction of the approach road, labour huts and foundations for pillars constituted genuine steps towards establishing the resort.
Referring to earlier judicial pronouncements, including the judgment in State of Himachal Pradesh versus M/s Barog Resorts Private Limited and other cases, Justice Sharma reiterated that vesting under Section 118 could not be treated as automatic merely upon expiry of two years.
The Court relied upon the principle laid down in an earlier Division Bench judgment in Ravinder Chauhan and others versus State of Himachal Pradesh, holding that failure to comply with the conditions for which permission had been granted must be attributable to conscious default, negligence or refusal on the part of the beneficiary.
The Court also referred to the judgment in M/s Springdale Resorts and Villas Private Limited versus State of Himachal Pradesh, observing that the statutory requirement to put land to its permitted use could not be interpreted narrowly to mean that the entire project must be completed within two years.
It emphasised that the legislative intent behind Section 118(2) was to ensure that meaningful and genuine steps were taken towards the permitted use of the land within the prescribed period. Completion of every component of a project within two years could not be insisted upon, particularly when several statutory permissions and departmental approvals were required before construction could proceed.
Finding that the petitioner had undertaken genuine construction activities within the prescribed period and that the delay was not attributable to conscious negligence, the Court held that the concurrent findings recorded by the Collector and Divisional Commissioner did not warrant interference.
Consequently, the High Court allowed the petition, quashed the Financial Commissioner’s order dated April 2, 2026, and permitted the company to complete the resort construction within one-and-a-half years from November 16, 2026. It directed that the property would vest in the State of Himachal Pradesh if the company failed to complete the construction within the extended period.
The judgment was delivered on November 16, 2026, in CWP No. 10130 of 2026, titled M/s Rikhi Resorts Private Limited versus State of Himachal Pradesh.
Himachal ki har badi khabar, sabse pehle aapke paas
Breaking news, local updates aur exclusive stories — seedha WhatsApp ya Email par. Free. No spam.
WhatsApp Alerts
Instant news seedha aapke phone par. Ek click me subscribe karein.
Subscribe on WhatsAppEmail Newsletter
Har nayi post ka link aapke inbox me. Kabhi bhi unsubscribe karein.