Shimla, Nov 21
In another landmark ruling safeguarding maternity rights of a woman government employee who was waging legal fight since nine years , Himachal Pradesh High Court has directed the state government to extend at least 12 weeks of maternity leave and other statutory benefits to petitioner delivering her third child, holding that maternity benefits couldnot be denied merely on the basis of restrictions under the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Vivek Singh Thakur and Justice Ranjan Sharma, on November 18, 2026, deciding a petition filed by Raksha Sawarwat, a regular JBT teacher, also clarified the scope of the State Government’s Office Memorandum dated July 31, 2009, to ensure that women employees having two or more surviving children receive maternity benefits under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961.
The court, however, declined to strike down Rule 43(1) of the CCS (Leave) Rules or quash the 2009 Office Memorandum, observing that doing so would amount to entering the legislative arena. Instead, it directed that the Office Memorandum be interpreted to extend maternity benefits under the Maternity Benefit Act to women employees having two or more surviving children at the time of childbirth.
The petitioner, who was appointed as a regular JBT teacher in the Education Department in 2002, had approached the court after the department rejected her application for maternity leave following the birth of her third child on July 24, 2017. She had applied for maternity leave from August 11, 2017, but the authorities declined the request, relying upon Rule 43(1) of the CCS Leave Rules, which provides for 180 days of maternity leave to a female government employee having less than two surviving children.
During the proceedings, the State Government defended the department’s action, contending that maternity leave of 180 days was admissible only in cases where a woman employee had fewer than two surviving children. The government also relied upon its Office Memorandum dated July 31, 2009, concerning the applicability of maternity benefit provisions to different categories of women employees.
The Division Bench, however, examined the provisions of the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, particularly Section 5(3), which expressly provides for 12 weeks of maternity benefits to a woman having two or more surviving children, as against 26 weeks for women having fewer than two surviving children.
The court held that the Maternity Benefit Act is applicable to government departments as well and has an overriding effect under Section 27 over inconsistent provisions contained in other laws, service rules or employment agreements. It observed that where service rules provide more favourable benefits, an employee would remain entitled to those benefits. However, where the rules provide no benefit or a lesser benefit, the statutory minimum under the Maternity Benefit Act could not be curtailed.
The Bench observed that maternity benefits could not be reduced below the statutory entitlement under the Act. It accordingly held that the petitioner was entitled to at least 12 weeks of maternity leave for the birth of her third child.
Explaining the constitutional basis of maternity protection, the court referred to Articles 42, 47 and 21 of the Constitution, observing that the right to health and the child’s right to maternal care immediately after birth form part of the broader protection guaranteed under Article 21.
The judgment also drew upon Supreme Court rulings in “Deepika Singh v. Central Administrative Tribunal” and “K. Uma Devi v. State of Tamil Nadu”, reiterating that childbirth must be treated as a natural incident of life and maternity leave provisions must be interpreted in a manner that advances social justice and enables women to continue in employment.
The Bench made it clear that it was not necessary to strike down Rule 43(1), as Section 27 of the Maternity Benefit Act itself provides the statutory mechanism to protect women against denial of minimum maternity benefits under service rules.
It similarly declined to quash the 2009 Office Memorandum but directed that it be read in a manner ensuring maternity benefits under the Act to women employees having two or more surviving children.
Setting aside the department’s rejection of the petitioner’s claim, the court directed the authorities to grant her 12 weeks of maternity leave along with all other admissible maternity benefits under the Act. The government has been directed to calculate and extend the consequential benefits by December 15, 2026.
The ruling is the second such intervention by the Himachal Pradesh High Court this year concerning maternity leave for the third child.
It interprets the existing 2009 Office Memorandum and applies the overriding protection under Section 27 of the Maternity Benefit Act. This distinction is important to avoid suggesting that the High Court itself has legislated or amended the service rules.
In August, Justice Sandeep Sharma had allowed maternity leave to staff nurse Archana Sharma, holding that the first two children being born before a woman joined government service could not automatically disqualify her from maternity benefits for a subsequent child.
In another recent ruling, Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua had also directed the State Government to grant 12 weeks of maternity leave to a 43-year-old TGT teacher for the birth of her third child, emphasising women’s dignity and constitutional protections under Articles 15, 21, 42 and 51.
The latest Division Bench judgment, however, goes further in clarifying the statutory entitlement of women employees with two or more surviving children and the applicability of the Maternity Benefit Act to government departments.
It interprets the existing 2009 Office Memorandum and applies the overriding protection under Section 27 of the Maternity Benefit Act. This distinction is important to avoid suggesting that the High Court itself has legislated or amended the service rules
Himachal ki har badi khabar, sabse pehle aapke paas
Breaking news, local updates aur exclusive stories — seedha WhatsApp ya Email par. Free. No spam.
WhatsApp Alerts
Instant news seedha aapke phone par. Ek click me subscribe karein.
Subscribe on WhatsAppEmail Newsletter
Har nayi post ka link aapke inbox me. Kabhi bhi unsubscribe karein.