Shimla, November 19
More than one-and-a-half years after a residential building collapsed and several adjoining houses suffered damage at Mathu Colony, Bhattakuffar, during construction of the Kaithlighat-Dhalli four-lane project, affected families are still awaiting full compensation as the contractor has challenged the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s directions before the Supreme Court.
The High Court, while hearing a suo motu Public Interest Litigation (CWPIL No. 61 of 2025) along with a connected petition (CWP No. 11091 of 2026) on November 16, took note of the proceedings before the Supreme Court and the resulting delay in disbursement of compensation.
A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice G.S. Sandhawalia and Justice Bipin C. Negi was informed that M/s Gawar Shimla Highway Private Limited, the contractor executing the four-lane project, had challenged the High Court’s August 5, 2026 order before the Supreme Court through Special Leave Petition (SLP) No. 34165 of 2026.
The High Court had earlier directed the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) and the contractor to share the compensation liability equally, with each required to bear 50 per cent of the assessed amount.
During the latest hearing, the court was informed that NHAI had already deposited its 50 per cent share of Rs 1,11,77,962. However, the Supreme Court, through its order dated October 5, 2026, granted a stay restraining recovery of the contractor’s share of compensation. Consequently, the affected family could not receive the entire amount despite the High Court’s earlier directions.
The High Court also allowed an application filed by Chanda Devi seeking impleadment as respondent No. 7 in the suo motu PIL. She had approached the court alleging damage to her residential building following the collapse of the adjoining house during execution of the four-laning work on National Highway-5.
Also Read HC Seeks NHAI Reply on Rs 600-Cr Land Acquisition for Bhatakufar -Dhali four laneÂ
The financial assessment placed before the High Court reveals that seven affected properties have suffered estimated losses aggregating to approximately **Rs 9.96 crore**. The State assessed the damage to Chanda Devi’s property at Rs 1,36,33,730, while the loss to Ranjana was assessed at Rs 2,22,57,436.
The assessment for other affected property owners included Rs 1,57,76,513 for Brij Lal, Rs 1,30,73,591 for Pradeep, Rs 1,69,24,045 jointly for Arun Thakur and Ankush Thakur, Rs 1,46,57,655 for Ashok and Rs 32,59,562 for Yogesh.
The Bench observed that both NHAI and the contractor would be liable to pay these assessed amounts in equal shares of 50 per cent each, in accordance with its earlier directions.
**However, the court’s latest order does not amount to a fresh award or immediate payment direction for the entire Rs 9.96 crore.** This figure represents the State’s aggregate assessment of losses suffered by the seven property owners. The earlier compensation direction specifically concerning Ranjana’s collapsed building and belongings was Rs 2,23,55,924, of which NHAI’s 50 per cent share of Rs 1,11,77,962 has already been deposited. The contractor’s corresponding share remains subject to the Supreme Court’s interim protection.
Thus, the total assessed damage of nearly Rs 9.96 crore, the earlier compensation direction of Rs 2.23 crore in Ranjana’s case and the amount already deposited by NHAI represent three distinct financial positions and should not be treated as interchangeable.
Taking note of the pending proceedings before the Supreme Court, the High Court refrained from issuing further directions at this stage. It directed the contractor to complete its pleadings in both cases, while Chanda Devi was also permitted to file her reply and claims.
The court listed the matter for further hearing on December 28, 2026.
The prolonged compensation dispute has once again brought into focus the accountability of infrastructure agencies and private contractors for damage to residential properties during highway construction in the fragile hill terrain of Himachal Pradesh, while affected families continue to face uncertainty over rehabilitation and financial relief.
Himachal ki har badi khabar, sabse pehle aapke paas
Breaking news, local updates aur exclusive stories — seedha WhatsApp ya Email par. Free. No spam.
WhatsApp Alerts
Instant news seedha aapke phone par. Ek click me subscribe karein.
Subscribe on WhatsAppEmail Newsletter
Har nayi post ka link aapke inbox me. Kabhi bhi unsubscribe karein.