Chandigarh, Nov 20
The Central Administrative Tribunal’s Chandigarh Bench has allowed a contempt petition filed by 29 retired BSNL employees from Himachal Pradesh, directing the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) and BSNL to release revised retiral benefits within four weeks. The petitioners, who include retired AGMs, SDEs, TOAs and other staff, have waited nearly seven years for compliance.
The order, reserved on September 25 and pronounced on November 16, 2026, by a bench of Ramesh Singh Thakur (Judicial Member) and Anjali Bhawra (Administrative Member), enforces the Tribunal’s January 23, 2019 judgment in OA No. 063/1192/2017.
The petitioners, originally DoT employees later absorbed into BSNL, had sought revision of pay and retiral benefits following the pay revision introduced from January 1, 2007, under a DPE Office Memorandum of November 26, 2008. A Presidential Directive of June 10, 2013 granted merger of 50% DA (effectively 78.2%) only prospectively. A DoT memorandum of July 18, 2016 gave pensioners who retired between January 1, 2007 and June 9, 2013 notional revision, with actual monetary benefit only from June 10, 2013.
The 2019 judgment held that once pay was revised, pension and consequential retiral benefits, including DCRG, commuted value of pension and leave encashment, must follow, and termed any distinction between pension and other benefits artificial. It relied on the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s decision in Het Ram v. HRTC and the Supreme Court’s ruling in State of Kerala v. N.M. Thomas.
Respondents’ stand
The respondents argued that a speaking order dated March 14, 2019 constituted compliance, as actual arrears for January 2007 to June 2013 were conditional on similar payment to serving employees, which was never made. They said DCRG, leave encashment and commutation were not revised because they were paid on the last pay actually drawn. They also relied on Sections 149 and 150 of the Finance Act, 2025, and the Validation Act, 2025, claiming retrospective effect from June 1, 1972. Several affidavits tendered unconditional apologies and denied wilful disobedience.
Petitioners’ arguments
Senior Advocate Onkar Jairath, appearing with Anshul Jairath, argued that the judgment had attained finality after the High Court’s admission of the writ petition in CWP No. 243 of 2023, the Supreme Court’s disposal of the SLPs on September 27, 2023, dismissal of the review on December 18, 2024 and of the curative petition on September 11, 2025. He contended that the Finance Act provisions concern Central Pay Commission recommendations and cannot apply to BSNL employees governed by the Public Enterprises pay regime. He also cited Madan Mohan Pathak v. Union of India, and pointed out that the Validation Act, notified March 29, 2025, was not raised in the curative petition.
Tribunal’s findings
The Bench held that issuing an order declining benefits is not compliance, and that respondents cannot substitute their own interpretation for a final judgment. It said the failed challenges before superior courts gave no liberty to disregard the directions. On the 2025 legislation, it held that the respondents cannot unilaterally treat the judgment as inoperative without a judicial determination of the law’s applicability to rights already adjudicated. It also noted that the respondents had failed to comply with the Daily Order of July 25, 2025, and that the apologies cannot substitute actual compliance.
Directions
The respondents must release revised DCRG/gratuity, commuted value of pension, leave encashment and consequential arrears, with dues of deceased applicants (six of 29, per counsel) paid to lawful heirs or nominees. The Bench barred them from confining compliance to a further communication or speaking order, warning of further proceedings, including action for wilful disobedience.
The matter is listed on December 23, 2026, when a compliance affidavit with proof of actual disbursement must be filed.
Himachal ki har badi khabar, sabse pehle aapke paas
Breaking news, local updates aur exclusive stories — seedha WhatsApp ya Email par. Free. No spam.
WhatsApp Alerts
Instant news seedha aapke phone par. Ek click me subscribe karein.
Subscribe on WhatsAppEmail Newsletter
Har nayi post ka link aapke inbox me. Kabhi bhi unsubscribe karein.