Shimla, Nov 21
The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has cracked down on alleged illegal mining activities in Kundlu Khad of Nalagarh in Solan district, exposing serious regulatory violations, the use of prohibited JCB machinery and extraordinary discrepancies between the river’s natural replenishment capacity and the volume of minerals authorised for extraction by the state authorities.
The environmental controversy has brought three stone crusher operations in the Nalagarh region under the scanner and raised serious questions about the functioning of the mining regulatory machinery in the vicinity of the Baddi-Barotiwala-Nalagarh (BBN) industrial belt, one of North India’s major industrial clusters.
In a significant intervention, the NGT has directed Himachal Pradesh authorities to ensure that no illegal mining takes place in the concerned stretch of Kundlu Khad, either by the three project proponents or any other person, until the next date of hearing.
The direction follows a damning investigation by a Tribunal-appointed Joint Committee, which found that mining operations had violated approved mining plans by deploying heavy machinery, excavating beyond permissible depths and disregarding sustainable sand mining guidelines.
The committee also uncovered a massive mismatch between the mineral extraction permissions granted to the three operators and the river’s assessed natural replenishment capacity, raising questions about the scientific basis on which such permissions were issued.
A Bench comprising NGT Chairperson Justice Prakash Shrivastava and Expert Member Dr Afroz Ahmad passed the order on November 18 in Original Application No. 637/2025, titled Bagga Ram and Others versus State of Himachal Pradesh and Others. The order was made available on November 21.
The controversy assumes particular significance as Kundlu Khad lies in the Nalagarh region, adjoining the BBN industrial corridor, where increasing pressure on natural resources, river systems and the surrounding environment has remained a matter of concern.
38.70 lakh tonnes permitted against replenishment capacity of 1.35 lakh tonnes
The most startling finding of the Joint Committee concerns the enormous quantity of minerals permitted to be extracted from Kundlu Khad despite its limited natural replenishment capacity.
According to the District Survey Report (DSR) of 2018, the Mining Department had assessed the annual replenishment capacity of Kundlu Khad at only 27,027 metric tonnes.
However, the three mining operations were collectively granted permission to extract 38,70,900 metric tonnes of sand, stone and bajri over five years.
This included 25,83,900 metric tonnes for Nalagarh Stone Crusher and R.P. Enterprises, 7,02,000 metric tonnes for Jai Mata Stone Crusher and 5,85,000 metric tonnes for Ruhani Stone Crusher.
Against the total permitted extraction of nearly 38.71 lakh tonnes, the river’s assessed replenishment capacity over the same five-year period worked out to approximately 1.35 lakh tonnes.
Thus, the authorised extraction quantity was approximately 28.6 times the assessed five-year replenishment capacity.
Also Read NGT seeks report on Stone supply to Crushers in Himachal over Illegal Mining concerns
The Joint Committee observed that the permitted mining capacity was substantially higher than the quantity justified by the DSR assessment. It further recorded that the quantities reflected in the DSR had already been extracted.
The committee had sought additional information from the project proponents, Mining Department and State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) to ascertain the reasons for granting permissions substantially exceeding the quantities specified in the survey report.
However, it recorded that no direct explanation had been received from the concerned authorities.
The discrepancy has raised serious questions about the scrutiny exercised by the regulatory authorities before granting environmental clearances and approving mining plans in the riverbed.
JCB machinery used despite explicit prohibition
The Joint Committee also established that the three mining operations had violated the conditions incorporated in their approved mining plans.
The plans specifically stipulated that no blasting was required and that only manual extraction of stone, sand and bajri could be undertaken. The mining trenches and pits were required to be restricted to a maximum depth of one metre and follow the normal direction of the river channel.
However, during the inspection, the committee discovered excavation exceeding the permissible one-metre depth at multiple locations in Kundlu Khad and within the areas covered by the three mining leases.
The committee observed that such excavation was unlikely to have been undertaken through manual labour and was most probably carried out using machinery.
The complainants produced geo-tagged photographs showing JCB machines being deployed for riverbed mining. The committee also examined freely available satellite imagery covering the previous five years to independently verify the allegations.
Of the three satellite images examined, one showed the presence of a JCB in the mining area.
On the basis of the physical inspection, photographic evidence and satellite imagery, the committee concluded that machinery had been used for riverbed mining despite the approved mining plans permitting only manual extraction.
The investigation also found violations of the Sustainable Sand Mining Management Guidelines, 2016, issued by the Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.
These guidelines prescribe that mining depth should be restricted to three metres and extraction must maintain a distance of three metres from the riverbank or 10 per cent of the river width, whichever is less.
They also require mining areas to be properly demarcated through pillars and geo-referencing before extraction begins.
The committee found that the project proponents had failed to comply with these safeguards, further strengthening the allegations of unregulated extraction in the riverbed.
Three stone crusher operators under scrutiny
The investigation identified three mining leases granted by the Mining Department in the concerned stretch of Kundlu Khad.
The first lease belongs to M/s Jai Mata Stone Crusher, operated by Mohan Singh, covering 165-09 bighas of government land at Dhalathon in Nalagarh tehsil.
The unit obtained environmental clearance from SEIAA on October 13, 2022. Its approved extraction capacity was 1,40,400 metric tonnes annually, amounting to 7,02,000 tonnes over five years.
The second operation, M/s Nalagarh Stone Crusher and R.P. Enterprises, is operated by Bidhi Chand and covers 1,069-16 bighas of government land across Taprian, Baglahar, Baniala and Kharuni villages.
SEIAA granted environmental clearance to the operation on July 3, 2021, permitting extraction of 25,83,900 metric tonnes over five years.
The third operation, M/s Ruhani Stone Crusher, operated by Amit Chandel, holds a mining lease over 102-02 bighas of private land at Androla Nichla in Nalagarh tehsil.
The unit obtained environmental clearance on June 24, 2023, permitting extraction of 5,85,000 metric tonnes over five years.
Together, the three operations were authorised to extract nearly 38.71 lakh metric tonnes of minerals from the concerned stretch.
The committee recommended that the mining plans and environmental clearances granted to all three project proponents be reassessed and suitably revised by the State Geologist and SEIAA in accordance with the provisions and mineral availability specified in DSR 2024.
It further recommended suspension of all three mining leases until the reassessment and revision exercise was completed.
The committee also recommended that fresh leases should be granted and existing leases renewed only after due examination and strict compliance with the quantities prescribed in DSR 2024.
Flash floods of 2025 damaged houses and agricultural properties
The mining controversy had acquired greater urgency following the devastating rainfall and flash floods of 2025, which caused damage to houses and agricultural properties belonging to several families living along the banks of Kundlu Khad.
The applicants had raised concerns about the possible relationship between excessive riverbed mining, environmental degradation and damage to properties in the surrounding areas.
However, the Joint Committee made an important distinction in its findings regarding the alleged connection between mining activities and landslides.
It observed that the landslides in the area had originated from the upper slopes and progressed downhill rather than from the lower slopes adjoining the river.
On this basis, the committee did not find sufficient evidence to establish a direct correlation between the landslides, damage to houses and agricultural land and the mining leases under examination.
The committee also approached the Public Works Department and Soil Conservation Department to explore possible remedial measures for restoration of the affected areas. However, neither department suggested any specific measures capable of addressing the damage.
The report separately examined the status of compensation claims filed by affected residents under the provisions of the Himachal Pradesh Disaster and Relief Manual.
It recorded that Bhagat Ram, a resident of Sauri village whose house was reportedly damaged during the 2025 disaster, had not received relief because his house was constructed on government land.
Petitioners Ram Lal and Ram Pal had not reported damage to their properties or claimed compensation under the disaster relief provisions.
The committee noted that Jadu Ram had reported the damage and his compensation claim had been granted. Relief had also been granted to Surjeet and Banto Devi, residents of Sauri village.
Meanwhile, the claims filed by Roop Lal, Naresh, son of Garebu, and Naresh, son of Ratna, residents of Sauri, had been returned to the applicants and were still under consideration.
NGT intervention puts mining regulatory machinery under scrutiny
The Joint Committee’s findings have raised wider questions about the monitoring of mining activities in the Nalagarh industrial belt, where allegations of indiscriminate extraction and environmental degradation have repeatedly surfaced.
Local journalists who have covered environmental destruction in the region have alleged that powerful mining interests enjoy political patronage and that regulatory and enforcement agencies have often failed to take decisive action against influential operators.
Speaking to Himachal Scape, a local journalist who has reported on environmental degradation in the area alleged that the mining lobby has considerable influence and that government officials and enforcement agencies have been reluctant to confront such operators directly.
The latest findings have particularly exposed the gap between the regulatory conditions imposed on paper and their enforcement on the ground.
The deployment of JCB machinery despite explicit restrictions, excavation beyond permissible depths and the extraordinary mismatch between authorised extraction and the river’s assessed replenishment capacity have brought the role of the Mining Department and environmental clearance authorities into sharp focus.
The NGT, after considering the Joint Committee’s report, observed that effective measures were required to prevent illegal mining in the concerned area.
During the hearing, counsel for the applicants also informed the Tribunal that illegal mining was allegedly continuing despite the investigation and submission of the committee’s report.
Also Read NGT directs crackdown on illegal mining in Kundlu Khad- Nalagarh, flags JCB use
Taking note of the submission, the Tribunal directed respondent No. 5 to ensure that no illegal mining by the project proponents or any other person takes place in the area until the next date of hearing.
The case has been listed for further hearing on February 1, 2027.
The coming months will test whether the state administration and enforcement agencies translate the Tribunal’s intervention into effective action by stopping illegal extraction, reassessing the existing mining permissions and ensuring accountability for regulatory violations.
For residents of the Kundlu Khad belt, the issue goes beyond the operations of three stone crushers. It concerns the protection of a river system, agricultural land, private properties and the ecological security of an area situated close to the rapidly expanding Baddi-Barotiwala-Nalagarh industrial corridor.
Legal clarification: The NGT’s operative direction expressly prohibits illegal mining in the concerned area until the next hearing. Suspension of the three mining leases is a recommendation of the Joint Committee, which the Tribunal considered; the order does not separately issue an express operative direction suspending all three leases. This distinction has been maintained in the report.
Himachal ki har badi khabar, sabse pehle aapke paas
Breaking news, local updates aur exclusive stories — seedha WhatsApp ya Email par. Free. No spam.
WhatsApp Alerts
Instant news seedha aapke phone par. Ek click me subscribe karein.
Subscribe on WhatsAppEmail Newsletter
Har nayi post ka link aapke inbox me. Kabhi bhi unsubscribe karein.