Fresh twist in Sanjauli Mosque dispute as Waqf Board pulls back appeal in High Court before maintainability hearing
Old photo used for indicative purpose only
Shimla, Dec 1,
Shimla’s long-contested Sanjauli Mosque dispute witnessed an unexpected turn on Monday when the Waqf Board withdrew its petition before the Himachal Pradesh High Court, moments before the crucial hearing on whether its appeal was even maintainable. The matter was listed before a Division Bench for arguments testing the very foundation of the Board’s challenge against the District Judge’s October 30 order, which had upheld the Municipal Commissioner’s directive for the demolition of the entire five-storey mosque structure in Sanjauli.
Counsel for the Waqf Board, B.S. Thakur, sought the court’s permission to withdraw the appeal, stating that the Board intended to amend its petition. The Bench allowed the withdrawal, effectively resetting a case that has stretched over sixteen years, drawn more than fifty hearings, and seen shifting positions by various parties at different stages of litigation.
The District Court, in its earlier verdict, had concluded that the construction stood on government land and lacked mandatory permissions, making both the Waqf Board and the Mosque Committee jointly accountable. Significantly, the Board was brought into the proceedings at a later stage, after the Shimla Municipal Commissioner had already found the three upper floors unauthorized. When Municipal Commissioner Bhupinder Atri later examined the matter afresh, he rejected the Board’s review plea and ruled that the entire structure violated municipal bye-laws, paving the way for a comprehensive demolition order.
The Board’s appeal filed on November 28 was its latest attempt to contest the District Court’s findings. However, Monday’s withdrawal indicates a recalibration in strategy, possibly aimed at addressing procedural gaps flagged in earlier hearings. With the High Court yet to examine any substantive arguments on the legality of the structure, the status of the remaining portion of the Sanjauli Mosque remains unresolved.
As the dispute enters yet another phase, the next steps of the Waqf Board—whether it seeks to re-file, amend, or entirely reshape its petition—will determine how the long-running case progresses. For now, the legal battle stands paused, even as the shadow of the demolition order continues to hang over the Sanjauli Mosque structure.
About the Author
The HimachalScape Bureau comprises seasoned journalists from Himachal Pradesh with over 25 years of experience in leading media conglomerates such as The Times of India and United News of India. Known for their in-depth regional insights, the team brings credible, research-driven, and balanced reportage on Himachal’s socio-political and developmental landscape.
